The News Chronicle
  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Thursday, August 11, 2022
  • Login
Advertisement
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
The News Chronicle
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Social Diary
  • Columns
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

Path Homepage » Editors' Pick » The Viral Blame Game: Xenophobia, Attribution and Coronavirus

The Viral Blame Game: Xenophobia, Attribution and Coronavirus

Dr. Binoy Kampmark by Dr. Binoy Kampmark
March 1, 2020
in Editors' Pick, Opinions
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Curfew Panda
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

Moralising the way diseases and viruses are transferred is a very human, and particularly nasty trait. “We don’t need this kind of riff-raff on our shores,” screamed The New York Times in 1892 in response to Russian Jewish immigrants arriving at Ellis Island by boat. (The occupants hosted lice which, in turn, led to typhus.)  

Italian immigrants in the United States would be also accused of being the bearers and spreaders of polio in 1916. Given that many, as a study by Alan Kraut from 2010 documents, lived in “tightly concentrated neighbourhoods, and because immigrants were viewed by many as a marginal and potentially subversive influence upon society, the incidence of Italian polio made a dramatic impact upon the imagination of a public already shaken by the virulence of the epidemic and the youth of its victims.”

RelatedPosts

The Veil

The Veil

August 11, 2022
The real conversation on Nigeria’s higher education

ASUU: Government can borrow if it must

August 11, 2022
Emergency In an Ambulance!

Emergency In an Ambulance!

August 11, 2022

In more recent times, the jaundiced eye nervously looked to the origin of AIDs, seeing dark Africa, exotic primates, bestiality. Ebola, as sociologist Kevin J.A. Thomas notes, received much the same press. When it infected some 28,000 across 10 countries some five years ago, “many people were surprised to learn that four of these cases were diagnosed on US soil.”

Nigeria 2023: Las las everybody go eat breakfast
Trending
Nigeria 2023: Las las everybody go eat breakfast

Follow the virus, find the maligned scapegoat. For COVID-19 (2019 novel coronavirus), a not negligible spray of suggestions claims that China, from eating habits, to politburo to the laboratory, is responsible for cultivation and transmission. One purportedly scientific paper authored by Botao Xiao and Lei Xiao claimed that the supposed origin of the virus – bats carrying CoV ZC45 – “were originally found in Yunnan or Zhejiang province, both of which were more than 900 kilometres from the seafood market [in Wuhan].” As the authors observed drily, “The probability was very low for the bats to fly to the market.”  

That paper has since been withdrawn, but the Wuhan Institute of Virology looms large in the conspiratorial consciousness. Why, for instance, did it have the highest security level – biosafety level 4? What were its researchers doing studying coronaviruses from bats? “Speculations,” claims Jon Cohen in Science, “have included the possibility that the virus was bioengineered in the lab or that a lab worker was infected while handling a bat and then transmitted the disease to others outside the lab.”

Such accounts of attribution have paved the way of fanciful presumptions. As a group of 27 public health scientists wrote in a rebuke in The Lancet, “The rapid, open, and transparent sharing of data on this outbreak are now being threatened by rumours and misinformation about its origins. We stand together to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that COVID-19 does not have a natural origin.” The point to keep reiterating, urged the authors, is that “this coronavirus originated in wildlife as have so many other emerging pathogens.”  

Russia Relationship with Africa Pegged on Delivering Pledges
Trending
Russia Relationship with Africa Pegged on Delivering Pledges

In the case of coronavirus, the xenophobes have come out barracking, and bigotry has taken root. At the Royal Children’s Hospital in Melbourne, Australia, staff have faced irate patients beside themselves at being treated by those of a certain race. (While not always reported, the imputation about Chinese appearance is never far away.) The Australasian College of Emergency Medicine has also issued warnings of a spike in racist abuse in emergency departments across the country.  

Dr Stuart Lewena, director of emergency medicine at the RCH, spoke of a particular incident. “One of our staff let us know that she had a family refuse to let her provide care for their child on the basis of her race, and what they declared was their concern that she was a risk of spreading coronavirus to them and their child.” To date, the state of Victoria has seen seven of Australia’s 23 confirmed cases of COVID-19. None of these has been transmitted locally within Australia.

Such instances have not been confined to hospital wards or those in need of treatment. Earlier this month, a woman wearing a face mask was allegedly assaulted in the New York City subway at the Grand Street station in Chinatown. An eyewitness reportedly claimed to hear the words “diseased b—-” uttered.

In the detritus of the social media sphere, campaigns combating “coronaracism” have also found legs. #JuNeSuisPasUnVirus made its debut on French twitter feeds in January 2020, and was duly replicated on other platforms such as Instagram. Australia’s own modest contribution to this came from Avani Dias, a journalist pushing the hashtag #DontDumpTheDumplings on February 13. This was, at least in part, intended as a remedy for dramatic declines in the patronage of Chinese restaurants in Sydney’s Chinatown. As Victor Tan, manager of the New Chilli House, told the radio program Hack, “We may not be killed by the virus but instead killed by the business environment.”

An agenda for national rebirth (1)
Trending
An agenda for national rebirth (1)

An even more concrete suggestion is to circulate material – visual and textual – that focuses on efforts at combating COVID-19. Leave aside the ghoulish images of alien bats and desperate masked Asian faces; focus, instead, on what Amanda Darrach of the Columbia Journalism Review calls “the logistics of providing care – an aspect of the story that involves Chinese people like medical professionals and activists”.

The great COVID-19 legacy will leave far fewer deaths than common influenza when the panic has dissipated. But fingers of stern accusation will continue being pointed, perceptions muddled by race and behaviour will continue to thrive, and losses, be it in terms of personal liberty or finance, will be tremendous. 

Dr. Binoy Kampmark was a Commonwealth Scholar at Selwyn College, Cambridge. He lectures at RMIT University, Melbourne. Email: bkampmark@gmail.com

Hot Gist

  • Photoprotection: Why You Need a Sunscreen
  • “I was disappointed by [Wole Soyinka’s] uncharacteristic silence between 2015 and 2019” – Farooq Kperogi
  • Importance of dentures in oral functions and aesthetics
  • “When I make a Mistake, it’s a Beauty” Fiorella H. La Guardia

Tags: Attribution and CoronavirusBlame GameEbolaXenophobia

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

Flavour thrills as 2020 Police Games kicks off in Anambra

Next Post

Amotekun, whither tiger, leopard, or cheetah

Related Posts

The Veil

The Veil

August 11, 2022
The real conversation on Nigeria’s higher education

ASUU: Government can borrow if it must

August 11, 2022
Emergency In an Ambulance!

Emergency In an Ambulance!

August 11, 2022
Sorrow, Tears and Blood: Nigeria A “Failed” State

2023: The fallacies of social media, stereotypes thinking and the reality of revolution

August 11, 2022
WHO IS STILL ARGUING THAT A LAWYER’S DOCUMENT PREPARED FOR HIS CLIENT WITHOUT AFFIXING THE NBA SEAL IS INCOMPETENT/IRREGULAR?!

Assuming Section 84 Of The Sheriffs And Civil Process Act, 2004, Was Validly Made By The Legislature

August 11, 2022
Enugu Politics

Living above the law

August 11, 2022
Next Post
Devils in the neighborhood

Amotekun, whither tiger, leopard, or cheetah

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

What's New?

The Veil
Opinions

The Veil

by Gerald Kure
August 11, 2022
0

‘When Moses finished speaking to them, he put a veil over his face. But whenever he entered the Lord’s presence...

Read more
Leadership Newspaper

  On the Podium with Tobi Amusan

August 11, 2022
The real conversation on Nigeria’s higher education

ASUU: Government can borrow if it must

August 11, 2022
Prev Next
The News Chronicle

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

News updates based on facts and evidence.