The News Chronicle
  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Tuesday, August 16, 2022
  • Login
Advertisement
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
The News Chronicle
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Social Diary
  • Columns
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

Path Homepage » Opinions » Folly and Falsities of Ruga Settlements

Folly and Falsities of Ruga Settlements

Oseloka H. Obaze by Oseloka H. Obaze
July 3, 2019
in Opinions
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Folly and Falsities of Ruga Settlements
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

Public policies are made in the public and collective interest. Essentially, policy experts agree that public policy making is a process and not a one-off event; it is thus “characterized as a dynamic, complex, and interactive system through which public problems are identified and countered by creating new public policy or by reforming existing public policy.” Where any policy is contrived to advance sectional or vested interests, that policy ceases to be in the common interest. And that is exactly where Nigeria finds itself with the controversial Rural Grazing Areas (RUGA) herdsmen settlement. The folly and falsities of that policy are deep-seated and very polarizing.

What is perhaps ever more disconcerting is the proclamation attributed to presidential spokesman, Mallam Garba Shehu, that “It is true that government at the centre has gazetted land in all the states of the federation.” The ensuing push back has been correctly strident; and criticisms of the policy trenchant. That is as it should be. Across board, ethnicity and across party lines, state governors are repudiating the policy. They were not consulted and they did not acquiesce. Neither did the Ninth Assembly give its legislative imprimatur. It seems the executive branch seized on the twilight and gray zone created by the transition from the Eight to the Ninth National Assembly to insinuate the controversial policy into the realm of extant laws. Such subterfuge is condemn-able in every regard.

RelatedPosts

Eedris Abdulkareem’s ‘Jaga Jaga’ And Nigeria’s Mess

   Becoming Poverty Champions; How Did We Do It

August 16, 2022
The Failings of Westminster: Scott Morrison’s Shadow Government

The Failings of Westminster: Scott Morrison’s Shadow Government

August 16, 2022
Nigeria’s Phenomenal Corruption Advancements

Forgotten Pacesetters and Faulty Leadership Recruitment

August 16, 2022
President Buhari Mourns Jigawa Apc Stalwart, Says A Good Man Has Been Lost
Trending
President Buhari Mourns Jigawa Apc Stalwart, Says A Good Man Has Been Lost

If the intent and goal of the federal government in approving the Ruga settlements programme was to curtail the problems associated with open grazing system, that intention has backfired awfully. The allegations of a hidden agenda seem correct and valid. The spectre of sectarianism is real. In theory and practice, every public policy ought to meet one of three definitional premises or a combination of two or all three to be efficacious. Hence public policies are essentially regulatory, distributive, or re-distributive. The Ruga policy does not in any sense meet any of these parameters.

First, the Ruga settlement programme serves only those engaged in the business of cattle rearing. There is no indication of how it would dovetail into the needs of farmers, who have for long been in conflict with herders. It does not cater to any other sector or trade in the commerce or organized private sector. Shockingly, it does not have the buy-in of states and local communities where the settlements will be domiciled.

Essentially, the Ruga scheme is a preferential policy contrived by executive fiat, which will only serve marginal and sectional interests at public expense. No adjectival qualification defines such a policy slant better than the word, “folly”.  Furthermore, Nigerians who are engaged on the matter now appreciate that the grounding premise, which is being masked as public interest is equally false. The way the policy is couched, hosting a Ruga settlement is not voluntary; it is decreed.

Theoretically, the Ruga policy does not pass the policy trajectory litmus test.  While the insecurity associated with farmers-herders conflict has been discussed extensively and various panaceas sought, arriving at the Ruga Scheme as the singular and one-size fits-all solution, overlooks and indeed, ignores the essential stages of good public policy making, namely; agenda setting, policy formulation, adoption, implementation and evaluation. It seems clearly that the federal government somersaulted forward – in a hop-step-and jump fashion – from agenda setting to implementation. Such policy rigmarole does not conjure confidence. It undermines trust; it raises more questions than it proffers solutions.

NDLEA uncovers 442 parcels of Crystal Meth in heads of smoked fish in Lagos as returnee excretes 77 wraps of Cocaine at Enugu airport
Trending
NDLEA uncovers 442 parcels of Crystal Meth in heads of smoked fish in Lagos as returnee excretes 77 wraps of Cocaine at Enugu airport

Beyond these observations, the federal government failed to convene town hall meetings to explore public reaction to such a divisive public policy. It also failed to call for the submission of memorandum from the public at large or interested parties, including public policy experts. Simply, the policy making was not interactive. Yet it seems the FGN want to foist the policy on the people by all means. And the FGN seem to have forgotten that freedom is the Holy Grail of democracy. In a true democracy, you can’t force on people what they don’t want. Government policies are not entrenched by subterfuge.

Another critical missing component that negates this policy approach is the absence of consultations within the three arms and three tiers of government. Seemingly, the decision on Ruga was done with military dispatch. But this is a democracy. For most of the presumed hosting state and local news communities, Ruga is literally and figuratively, a Greek Gift and a Trojan Horse.

Finally, in proposing to set up Ruga settlement, the “eminent domain” clause cannot apply.  Neither can the provisions of the Land Use Act be contrived as applicable. The pertinent proviso, stipulates that the use of any land so acquired, must be for “public purposes,” which may include housing development, road and bridges, schools, hospitals, police and military barracks and recreation parks.  Private land cannot be acquired in the public interest and devolved to private profit making enterprises. Ruga should be like the fiscal bailout. Only those states that need or want it should get it.

This pain is too much for me, leave Manchester United, Mr Macaroni tells Ronaldo
Trending
This pain is too much for me, leave Manchester United, Mr Macaroni tells Ronaldo

The Ruga policy is fraught with folly and falsities. It has unquestionable ethnic coloration; and its processes are bereft of full disclosure. Indubitably, Ruga is not your quixotic think-outside-the-box solution. It is a bad policy that, in the short to long term, will do more harm than good. From the push back so far, the FGN ought to know by now that it must resile itself and rescind the policy – in the public and national interest.

—————

* Obaze is MD/CEO Selonnes Consult – a policy, governance, and management consultancy firm, in Awka.

Hot Gist

  • “The precise mechanism of action in chloroquine is poorly understood”, Pharmacist Iniobong Usen
  • The Story Vault. #1. Love
  • Sunday Reflections
  • Catherine M. O’Meara’s Optimism in Crisis, and Comparison between the 1918 and 2019 Pandemics

Tags: FGNherdsmenMallam Garba ShehuRuga SettlementTrojan Horse

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

USA into World Cup final after a 2-1 victory over England

Next Post

Murray, Serena form Wimbledon mixed doubles dream team

Related Posts

Eedris Abdulkareem’s ‘Jaga Jaga’ And Nigeria’s Mess

   Becoming Poverty Champions; How Did We Do It

August 16, 2022
The Failings of Westminster: Scott Morrison’s Shadow Government

The Failings of Westminster: Scott Morrison’s Shadow Government

August 16, 2022
Nigeria’s Phenomenal Corruption Advancements

Forgotten Pacesetters and Faulty Leadership Recruitment

August 16, 2022
Egypt: 239 Churches And Places Of Worship Legalized By Government Committee

A Model Church

August 16, 2022
Watching Self From The Outside

Watching Self From The Outside

August 15, 2022
First Bank affirms commitment to empowering youths

First Bank affirms commitment to empowering youths

August 15, 2022
Next Post
Murray, Serena form Wimbledon mixed doubles dream team

Murray, Serena form Wimbledon mixed doubles dream team

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

What's New?

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Analytics: Accelerating Africa’s Hydrocarbon Sector Development
Africa

Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Analytics: Accelerating Africa’s Hydrocarbon Sector Development

by Adams Peter
August 16, 2022
0

With Africa pursuing the exploitation of its hydrocarbon reserves to address growing energy poverty and fuel industrialization, artificial intelligence (AI)...

Read more
Eedris Abdulkareem’s ‘Jaga Jaga’ And Nigeria’s Mess

   Becoming Poverty Champions; How Did We Do It

August 16, 2022
Jurgen Klopp speaks positively of his players following a frustrating draw at Anfield

Jurgen Klopp speaks positively of his players following a frustrating draw at Anfield

August 16, 2022
Prev Next
The News Chronicle

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

News updates based on facts and evidence.