The National Commission for Refugees, Migrants, and Internally Displaced Persons (NCFRMI) is fast degenerating to cesspool of corruption and mismanagement due to the brash and reckless manner the place has been run by the new Federal Commissioner, Mrs. Imaan Sulaiman-Ibrahim, according to media reports. It is impunity and disregards for due process that breed corruption, not just in the Commission, but in Nigeria as a whole.
Signs emerged quite early showing that the new Commissioner was going to run a one-woman show when, without waiting for handover, she threw out the picture and personal belongings of her predecessor, Senator Bashir Garba Lado. She also allegedly stormed Senator Lado’s private residence to confiscate the official vehicles used by the said predecessor rather than wait for the official handover or request that vehicles be returned as required by civilized conduct.
The tragedy that the Commission has become is rather unfortunate if the primary statutory responsibility of the federal agency is considered. The National Commission for Refugees, Migrants and IDPs (NCFRMI) was established by Decree 52 of 1989 now Cap. N21, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 2004 (NCFRMI Act). This was in fulfillment of the Federal Government’s obligation under Resolution 319 (IV) of the General Assembly of the United Nations and Article 35 of the United Nations 1951 Convention.
The National Commission for Refugees (NCFR) as it was then called was initially only responsible for managing the affairs of refugees. However, in 2002, former President Olusegun Obasanjo enlarged the mandate to include migrants and internally displaced persons, and this was the beginning of the expanded responsibilities of the commission. Over the years, the NCFRMI has approached its mandate of providing care and maintenance as well as durable solutions to all its persons of concern (PoCs), which include refugees, internally displaced persons, stateless persons, and returnees among others with keen sense of responsibility.
The well-cut out, three-pronged job of the Commission summarily is to articulate and implement the response of the Federal Government to the growing humanitarian crisis in Nigeria. But under the current leadership, the Commission is getting more and more weakened as the Honourable Federal Commissioner carries on like lord of the manor, fragrantly violating due process and introducing policies and programmes that cannot promote the work of the agency.
The reign of impunity has ushered in flagrant disregard for procurement procedures to the extent that the management staff are not privy to the information of what the funds are spent on. For instance, the Procurement Tenders Board (PTB) members in the agency are not in the know of the details of the N8bn released to the agency most recently.
The HFC cannot be allowed to run the Commission as a private business. Even organized private businesses are not run by a single individual let alone a federal agency, which has approved guidelines and due process governing expenditure. Yet in the Commission, both PTB members and the management staff are sidelined in matters as serious as expending the funds of the Commission.
Even the ministers of the Federal Republic of Nigeria take their requests for approvals of contracts and procurements to the Federal Executive Council and not sit in the ministries and authorize expenditure. Why then is the head of the Commission not submitting to financial regulations and fiscal discipline to allow for transparency, probity and accountability?
Meanwhile, key international partners are said to be considering pulling out of partnership with NCFRMI due to the opaque and rancorous manner the Commission is run. Such international partners operate in climate of sure process and open governance.They are aware that some of their financial and material support do not always get to the beneficiaries in fidelity to their purpose clause.
For example, she is said to have refused to release a Toyota brand-new SUV operational vehicle donated to the Maiduguri office by the United Nations High Commission for Human Rights, UNCHR. How akward can things get in our country? It is a well-known fact that most of Nigeria’s IDPs are in the North East, especially Borno State. So, why on earth would any reasonable and responsible Nigerian deliberately deny the Maiduguri office of the Commission a very critical logistic like an operational vehicle to try to meet the herculean demand? Someone should tell her that when the foreign partners pull out or refuse to give a helping hand in the area of mobility, it can only hamper the works of the Commission the more since international donor agencies are a major source of financial and technical support to the Commission.
What is more, a prudent chief executive of a government agency saddled with humanitarian affairs of a country shouldn’t expend 35m in furnishing her office that was renovated and furnished less than 6 months before she resumed as head of the Commission. These are the kind of things the international community would read and wonder the kind of people we are. Ministers and heads of agencies in the countries that lend us help use public transport. They don’t stay in ostentatious offices. But our ministers and government functionaries fly in chattered aircraft and furnish offices with multi-million naira.
Ironically, the zonal and field offices, which pictures this writer has in front of him as he writes are an eyesore. They lack basic tables and chairs, while the available ones are torn and shabby. Even the appearances of the offices alone can easily siphon the entire energy and motivation left in the most patriotic worker.
Another troubling practice at the Commission is her penchant for anticipatory approval, which entails incurring huge and oftentimes frivolous and bloated expenditures with funds yet to be received. This is against the Procurement Act and its extant express provisions, which stipulate that approvals must be based on availability of funds. One understands that Director Legal of the Commission who she threw out of the Commission was because he rightly opposed and raised serious issues of illegality of anticipatory approvals. The Director Procurement was also sent packing by her for equally insisting on due process and accountability. Now, she has in place “O! Yes” people in procurement, who one understands she brought from NAPTIP, and who are ever ready to do her bidding.
Another poster boy of the decadence and decline that the NCFRMI is fast becoming is the so-called Operation Zero Hunger. The Commission used to provide relief materials for households – which the Mrs. Iman is trying to replace with zero hunger. The Project, which only the Federal Commissioner knows anything about in the Commission is a “collabo” between the agency and Defence and Police Officers Wives Association. But this is the real spelling of “from frying pan to fire” for IDPs and other PoCs. For Instance, the usual household package given to IDPs consists of at least 100kg of grains; 25kg each of rice, beans, maize and millet or garri; 20 litres of vegetable; 20 litres of palm oil; and other household items such as mattresses, mats, pots and packs of sanitary wares, amongst others. But she is phasing this out with a small pittance for individuals with only 1 kg of grains, and pack of sphagetti in each pack, dorned by her personal picture. That is what obtains since the Commissioner switched to Project Zero Hunger, which indeed should be more aptly called operation more hunger.
This cannot possibly continue. Certainly not.
First, with the sad tales in the media, there is now a great need for the protection of staff members, including some union members, who have been constantly threatened with sack and deployment to field offices. Mrs. Sulaiman-Ibrahim should be made to understand that disagreeing to her whims and caprices when they run foul of the rules and policies is not tantamount to disloyalty. Not praising her to high heavens or massaging her over-bloated ego is also not the same thing as disloyalty. Besides, the primary loyalty of civil servants and indeed any Nigerian for that matter is first to the Federal Republic of Nigeria, not one chief executive that doesn’t know that a government agency is neither her patrimony or fiefdom.
Again, Mr. President needs to have the EFCC and ICPC carry out a thorough investigation of the procurement and finance processes of the Commission to ensure that the persons of concern, PoCs, for who the agency was created, are not continually shortchanged. Surely, Nigerians would be eager to know more about the Commission’s funds expended on Operation Zero Hunger and how it has bettered the lots of the IDPs more than what we have always known. One strongly recommends this scrutiny after comparing what the Commission used to hand out to IDPs and what is being handed out now under the new scheme.
Lest one forgets, Mrs. Imaan Sumailan-Ibrahim should be reminded that she is a chief executive of a federal humanitarian agency, not a state governor or minister or Senate President. For crying out loud, what on earth is she doing with all the personal and security aides, the convoy that includes siren-blaring pickup vans, and serving and retired personnel of critical federal government security agencies, including the Department of State Security, National Intelligence Agency, Defence Intelligence Agency, etc? What the hell is she doing with almost 20 personal aides drawn from outside the Commission? What is she doing with a Chief of Staff, especially one drawn from outside the Commission?
Yet there is a lesson in all this: we should hire people based on competence, not as a form of political patronage. It is understood that Mrs. Imaan Sumailan-Ibrahim was not qualified to head both NAPTIP and NCFRMI if we had followed the laws. She was trading in cosmetics (Mary Kay) overseas, came home in 2018 to vie for a seat in the House of Representatives, then failed but was appointed as a Special Assistant in the Ministry of Education before she was appointed the DG of NAPTIP. We recall how some people shouted to high heavens that she wasn’t qualified to run NAPTIP based on the Act establishing the agency, but only for her to be upgraded to a bigger agency. It could now be seen why she doesn’t know her left from her right and why she is so insecure. I’m a trained psycologist. If you did deeper, it will not be surprising if her alleged impunity and executive excesses are partly products of insecurity.
Whatever it is, however, the woman just has to be called to order. Her impunity, flagrant disregard for due process, lack of transparency and accountability coupled with staff grievances against her for highhandedness and toxic leadership are all combining to take the Commission from bad to worse.
The National Commission for Refugees, Migrants, and Internally Displaced Persons (NCFRMI) is just too important to be allowed to wallow under such administration. It is becoming more and more unable to fulfill its care mandates amidst the growing humanitarian crisis in the country. A stitch in time, they say, saves nine.
Dr. Law Mefor is a Senior Fellow of The Abuja School of Social and Political Thought; Tel.: +234- 905 642 4375 E-mail: email@example.com; follow me on twitter:@LawMefor1.