The News Chronicle
  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
Sunday, August 14, 2022
  • Login
Advertisement
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist
  • Gossip
No Result
View All Result
The News Chronicle
No Result
View All Result
  • News
  • Social Diary
  • Columns
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

Path Homepage » Editors' Pick » Africa and the Danger of Resource-backed Loans from China

Africa and the Danger of Resource-backed Loans from China

Jideofor Adibe by Jideofor Adibe
February 27, 2020
in Columns, Editors' Pick, Featured, Thursday
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
Atiku’s Amnesty Plan for Suspected Treasury Looters is the Way to Go
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

When I got an email from the Natural Resource Governance Institute (NRGI) informing me of a planned press release today (Thursday, February 27 2020) of a study it conducted on the impact of resource-backed loans on some African countries, my curiosity was aroused. NRGI is an NGO led by Daniel Kaufmann, a respected economist and non-resident senior fellow at Brookings Institution, with its board chaired by the former President of Mexico, Ernesto Zedillo. It receives funding from such respectable donors as Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, the Ford Foundation, Luminate, the Open Society Foundations, the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, the governments of Germany, Norway, Switzerland, the United Kingdom and the United States, as well as from multilateral institutions such as the World Bank and the African Legal Support Facility.

NRGI’s report entitled, ‘Resource-Backed Loans: Pitfalls and Potential’ called on African leaders to come clean on the terms of high value resource-backed loans.  Resource-backed loans are arrangements in which resource-endowed countries access finance in exchange for, or collateralized by future streams of income from such natural resources as oil or solid minerals.

RelatedPosts

Sanusi4sure

Insecurity: Nigeria under threat of revolution

August 13, 2022
Leadership Newspaper

  On the Podium with Tobi Amusan

August 11, 2022
The real conversation on Nigeria’s higher education

ASUU: Government can borrow if it must

August 11, 2022
Okowa heaps praises on Tobi Amusan
Trending
Okowa heaps praises on Tobi Amusan

Despite NRGI’s credibility, I have had lingering suspicions about Western-backed reports about China’s role in Africa.  In fact in an article in this column on January 9 2020 entitled, ‘Is China really taking over Africa without firing a shot’? I wrote:

“Of course any analysis of China’s role in Africa risks being caught in the web of the rivalry (or jealousy) between China and the continent’s former colonial masters and traditional allies: if it is too critical of China’s role in the continent, it is suspected of oozing of Western bias or playing out a Western script.

“If it is too welcoming of Chinese presence, it is suspected of trying to ingratiate oneself to China or even externalising one’s sub-conscious disappointments with the continent’s traditional allies and former colonial masters.What is obvious is that the influence of China, (which overtook USA as Africa’s biggest trading partner in 2009), is growing by leaps and bounds in the continent.”

The NRGI claimed its aim in undertaking the study was to explore the risks and opportunities that resource-backed loans present and to offer policy recommendations on how both borrowers and lenders can improve on the practice. It said its researchers studied 52 resource-backed loans made between 2004 and 2018, with a total value of more than $164 billion and found that 30 of these, with a combined value of $66 billion, were made to sub-Saharan African countries. “Of the loans to sub-Saharan African countries considered by the researchers, 53 percent of the amount borrowed came from two Chinese policy banks: China Development Bank (CDB) and the China Eximbank. Most of the remainder was provided by international commodity traders, mainly to Chad, Republic of Congo and South Sudan.”, the report said.

President Buhari Celebrates Team Nigeria As Medal Galore Increases To 35 At 2022 Commonwealth Games
Trending
President Buhari Celebrates Team Nigeria As Medal Galore Increases To 35 At 2022 Commonwealth Games

The report identified four African countries where it said resource-backed loans have particularly contributed significantly to exacerbate their debt problems: Angola, Chad, Republic of Congo and South Sudan. It also analysed both Ghana and Guinea’s recent resource-backed loan deals with China. For Ghana, it noted that “Ghana’s government is obligated to repay a $2 billion loan it agreed with Chinese state company Sinohydro in 2018. The repayment schedule requires a rapid ramp-up of bauxite production and refining, which the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has warned may not be possible and therefore could lead to loss of collateral.”

And for Guinea, it wrote: “Guinea signed a $20 billion loan in 2017, equivalent to 200 percent of the country’s GDP. Bauxite production, designated to repay the loan, has already started, but there is little publicly available information on how the country will repay such an enormous loan and under what conditions. Bauxite production in both countries carries significant environmental risks, but the affected citizens and the civil society organizations that represent them have been effectively shut out of any consultations about the loans.”

Some of the deleterious effects of resource-based loans, the NRGI said, included their being shrouded in secrecy, contributing to Africa’s unsustainable debt levels and the risk of losing the collateral on which those loans are secured and which are usually worth more than the value of such loans.

The report said that loans from “commercial oil trading companies” are particularly problematic, especially with specific regard to the terms for securing such loans and repayment modalities: Quoting David Mihalyi, a co-author of the report, it said: “These deals, sometimes labelled as oil advances, often resemble pay-day loans: they have short maturities, high interest rates and fees, and no commitments on how the money will be used. Countries should stay away from oil advances containing such harmful terms.”

Come back home, Omokri tells Peter Obi
Trending
Come back home, Omokri tells Peter Obi

The report tried to establish a link (unconvincingly in my opinion), between resource-backed loans and corruption and poor governance, saying,

“Of the eleven sub-Saharan African countries that took out resource-backed loans, eight received poor or failing scores on the Resource Governance Index, which includes among its assessments measures of transparency and accountability of countries’ resource sectors.

“Angola, which took out the largest amounts of resource-backed loans in Africa, is currently mired in a large-scale corruption case involving its state-owned oil company, Sonangol. And the Republic of Congo was embroiled in a major scandal involving representatives of commodities trading giant bribing public officials to gain access to its oil markets.” The idea that resource-backed loans correlate positively with poor governance and corruption will seem to suggest wrongly that the quality of governance is better and corruption is less in African countries that are not endowed with natural resources or that are not involved in cash-backed loans from China.

Though the report conceded that countries resorting to resource-backed loans could get cheaper financing  which can be used to generate economic returns  that will in the long run exceed their financing cost,  it said  there is a need for caution“given the largely negative experiences documented in the report”. It proffered a number of recommendations including “ensuring that key loan terms are vetted by ministries of finance and available to the public; obtaining flexibility of repayments; ‘shopping around’ with a variety of lenders to optimize terms; and employing legal experts for contract negotiations.”

One of my issues with the report is that it focuses excessively on China as the ‘bad guy’ that drives resource-backed loans in developing world, especially in sub-Saharan Africa. The truth however is that Standard Chartered Bank, a British multinational bank with headquarters in London, was one of the first lenders to use resource-backed financing in Africa. It used it to finance the Angolan government’s demand for revenue during its war with Jonas Savimbi’s UNITA rebels. For instance in an article in September 2013 for the World Bank entitled, ‘Resource-Backed Investment Finance in Least Developed Countries’, by Håvard Halland and Otaviano Canuto, the authors remarked: “In the absence of a credible sovereign guarantee, given the Angolan government’s low creditworthiness at the time, Standard Chartered offered an arrangement whereby its lending was to be guaranteed by future oil revenues. Other Western banks soon followed suit, including BNP Paribas of France, Commerzbank of Germany and others, and by the end of the war in 2002, the Angolan government had taken out 48 oil-backed loans.”  It was actually during the wave of resource-backed financing that China Exim Bank in 2004 started offering its own version of such loans – the so-called RfI deals – which it also pioneered in Angola and which was later to become a main vehicle for financing that country’s post-war reconstruction.

Despite its heaviness on China, the report calls very useful attention to the dangers of resource-backed loans – the opacity surrounding the loans and the dangers of mortgaging a country’s subsoil wealth without much to show for it.  Remarkably in an article on February 2 2018 entitled ‘Ensuring a Fair Deal for Nigerians with Oil-Backed loan’, the NRGI wrote:

“Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation (NNPC) is reportedly looking to secure an oil-backed loan from major oil trading companies to finance hydrocarbon projects (along with related infrastructure). The cash-for-crude deal would provide payment of USD 3.5-5 billion to NNPC in exchange for 70,000 barrels of oil per day (bpd) over 5 to 7 years. Major traders such as Glencore, Vitol and Trafigura have shown interest, while Standard Chartered would advise on the financial structure of the deal.”

The report warned: “If this loan is not carefully structured and managed, it could mortgage the country’s resource wealth without much productive return. It also poses major fiscal risks, especially to how much money the government collects from NNPC.”

Perhaps Nigerians can use the opportunity of the report not only to ask the government to come clean on its resource-backed loans  but also to update them about the reported oil-backed loan that the NNPC was said to be searching for in 2018.

____________________________
Email: pcjadibe@yahoo.com

Twitter: @JideoforAdibe

 

Hot Gist

  • “The precise mechanism of action in chloroquine is poorly understood”, Pharmacist Iniobong Usen
  • The Story Vault. #1. Love
  • Sunday Reflections
  • Catherine M. O’Meara’s Optimism in Crisis, and Comparison between the 1918 and 2019 Pandemics

Tags: China EximbankNatural Resource Governance Instituteresource-backed loansStandard Chartered Bank

Get real time update about this post categories directly on your device, subscribe now.

Unsubscribe
Previous Post

The Catholic Church, Peaceful Coexistence and Nation Building in Nigeria 

Next Post

EFCC denies own statement against Shehu Sani in court

Related Posts

Sanusi4sure

Insecurity: Nigeria under threat of revolution

August 13, 2022
Leadership Newspaper

  On the Podium with Tobi Amusan

August 11, 2022
The real conversation on Nigeria’s higher education

ASUU: Government can borrow if it must

August 11, 2022
If Only

Securing our people

August 10, 2022
Lady swears by mother’s grave that she has never cheated on her boyfriend

I’m rich, educated, sexually active, yet my wife cheated on me – Man cries out

August 10, 2022
Sadiq Umar recounts how he was humiliated at Rangers, Glasgow

Sadiq Umar recounts how he was humiliated at Rangers, Glasgow

August 9, 2022
Next Post
EFCC denies own statement against Shehu Sani in court

EFCC denies own statement against Shehu Sani in court

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ADVERTISEMENT

What's New?

Gabriel Jesus scores twice in Arsenal’s terrific win over Leicester City
Sports

Gabriel Jesus scores twice in Arsenal’s terrific win over Leicester City

by Oladimeji Adeoye
August 13, 2022
0

Arsenal picked their second victory today at the Fly Emirates Stadium over Leicester City in a six goals thriller match....

Read more
Plans Fail: Ideas Do Not

Stand And Watch

August 13, 2022
Done Deal: Emmanuel Dennis joins Nottingham Forest from Watford

Done Deal: Emmanuel Dennis joins Nottingham Forest from Watford

August 13, 2022
Prev Next
The News Chronicle

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Navigate Site

  • About Us
  • Advert Rates
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Breaking
    • Business
    • Celebs
    • Sports
    • Africa
    • Technology
    • World News
    • Interviews
  • Social Diary
    • Events
  • Columns
    • Monday
    • Tuesday
    • Wednesday
    • Thursday
    • Friday
    • Sunday
    • Opinions
    • Editorial: Our Stand
  • TNC TV
  • Interviews
  • Books
    • Reviews
    • Author Profiles
  • Entertainment
  • Gist

© 2022 The News Chronicle

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

News updates based on facts and evidence.